"Refactor a 500-line React component into smaller composable hooks"
Cursor's Composer 2 breaks the file into 4 custom hooks and a thin wrapper component, showing a diff preview at each step. You approve or reject each extraction individually. Clean, predictable results with full developer oversight.
Windsurf's Cascade agent analyzes the full component tree, identifies shared state patterns, and autonomously creates 5 hooks plus a context provider. It also updates all 12 importing files. Fast but occasionally over-abstracts.
Why Tie wins: Cursor's step-by-step approach gave more predictable, reviewable results. Windsurf was faster but created an unnecessary context provider.
"Debug a failing CI pipeline with cryptic TypeScript errors"
Cursor's agent reads the error log, traces it to a mismatched type in a shared interface, and proposes a targeted fix to 2 files. Required one follow-up prompt to also update the test file.
Windsurf's Cascade reads the CI log, cross-references the codebase index, identifies the root cause, fixes the type mismatch across 3 files including tests, and runs the linter — all in one pass.
Why Tie wins: Windsurf's autonomous multi-step execution solved the entire issue chain without needing follow-up prompts.
Compare Cursor and Windsurf side-by-side with your own prompts — free.
Try NailedIt.ai →